Ham and Cheese Toasties Banned in WA Schools: Nutrition Overreach or Healthy Move

In a move that's got parents, students, and toastie aficionados across Western Australia scratching their heads in bewilderment, the classic ham and cheese toastie has been given the boot from school canteens. 

Yes, you read that right. The lunchtime staple that has fueled generations of Aussie kids has been shown the red light, joining the ranks of chips, lollies, and other deemed unhealthy snacks that are banned from sale, as first reported this week by the Daily Mail.

Is this crackdown on the humble toastie a step too far?

A ham and cheese toastie
A ham and cheese toastie.


The recent overhaul of the school food and drink rules, which now sees ham as a 'red' item in the traffic light classification, has sparked a heated debate. 

Since 2007, this system has been guiding the nutritional dos and don't's of school canteens, with green signalling go for nutritious items, amber for those to be consumed in moderation, and red for the no-go zone. Up until now, ham and cheese toasties were basking in the green glow of approval while a plain ham sarnie was lounging comfortably in amber territory.

Fast forward to today, and it seems the rules have taken a sharp turn. With processed meats being linked to a higher risk of bowel cancer, the decision might not seem entirely out of left field.

Seeing Red Over Green: The Traffic Light Food Drama Unpacked

school canteen pie
The Aussie classic, a meat pie from the canteen.


However, the Western Australian School Canteen Association chief, Megan Sauzier, is raising an eyebrow at this new directive. She points out the significant strides already made towards healthier school canteens – no salami, mortadella, deep-fried chips, soft drinks, or sweets. So, the burning question on everyone's lips is, do we really need to say goodbye to ham as well?

The plot thickens as sausage rolls, pies (even those reduced-fat darlings), and oven-baked wedges find themselves relegated to the 'selected red items' list. And let's not even start on the cakes and biscuits that have gone from amber to red faster than you can say "jam drop." On the flip side, full-fat dairy products have leapt from amber to green in a twist that's left many cheering for cheese.

But here's where it gets a tad confusing. Fruit juice slushies are now seeing red, but their unfrozen counterparts are still chilling in amber. And in a surprising turn of events, some flavoured waters have gone from red to green. It's enough to make your head spin!

Healthy lunch
A delicious packed lunch. 


The Western Australia Health Department assures that there's no hard deadline for schools to implement these changes, which kicked off at the start of Term 1. Yet, with the education department suggesting schools chat with parents about what makes the menu cut, it's clear this toastie tale is far from over.

Jim Bell, from the Education Department, insists this isn't a ban but a nudge towards healthier choices, with schools still able to serve up these now-red items, provided the menu remains 60% green. It's all about balance, folks.

As the dust settles on this culinary controversy, one has to wonder, is the ban on ham and cheese toasties a well-intentioned push for healthier eating, or has the pursuit of nutrition gone a tad overboard? With the risk of processed meats well-documented, perhaps there's merit in the madness. 

But as any Aussie kid (or adult, for that matter) will tell you, there's nothing quite like the comforting embrace of a warm, cheesy toastie. So, Western Australia, have we gone too far? Or is this just the wake-up call our school canteens needed? Only time, and perhaps a few more nutrition advisory meetings, will tell.

More Parenting Tips

Easy Self-Care Ideas For Busy Mums
Magnesium for Kids: The Ultimate Guide for Boosting Kids' Health
Understanding School Zone Rules in Australia: The Ultimate No-BS Guide

Have you signed up for our newsletter? Join ellaslist to get the best family and kid-friendly events, venues, classes and things to do NEAR YOU!